Strategy for C.O.D. Service
December 1957 Radio & TV News Article

December 1957 Radio & TV News

[Table of Contents] Wax nostalgic about and learn from the history of early electronics. See articles from Radio & Television News, published 1919-1959. All copyrights hereby acknowledged.

Deadbeat customers have been a problem since time immemorial. Said dirt bags ask you to perform a service and/or provide a product and then either try to cheat you out of full payment or refuse to pay at all. Back in the days when repairmen made in-home visits for radio and television sets, evidently the problem could be really bad. Art Margoli wrote this article for Radio & TV News describing methods he devised to handle, and most importantly avoid, uncomfortable situations and stave off ugly confrontations with customers. One such scheme was to have customers sign a "cognovit note," which is an extraordinary document by which a debtor authorizes his or her creditor's attorney to enter a confession in court that allows judgment against the debtor. Of course litigation would probably cost more than the bill was worth and therefore would not likely be pursued, but the cognovit note appeared intimidating with sufficient legalese to give pause to the seasoned feckless homeowner. If you are in business for yourself and have similar issues, maybe something here will work for you. Fortunately, I have only had a couple incidences of companies not paying according to my very lenient terms.

Strategy for C.O.D Service

The chief customer types who try to defer prompt payment and the techniques for discouraging them.     Fig. 1 - One defective component caused another in this circuit.

About a year ago the owner of a busy three man TV service organization, a friend of the writer, was handed an ultimatum from his ac­countant. The accountant stated, "You either raise your service charge or cut out your credit business."

Delinquent accounts had reached a new high of twelve-hundred dollars. The expense of billing and special collection trips were eating deeply into the profits. Since his service charge was considerable already, the TV expert decided to go on the C.O.D. standard.

He quickly discovered there was one big problem with being strictly C.O.D. What do you do with the customers who still ask for credit? A strict adherence to refusal of credit was sending a percentage of his clientele elsewhere for TV service. He was faced with the enigma of how to give some customers a form of credit yet remain essentially on the C.O.D. standard.

Since the author's service outfit has always been C.O.D., the technician called on the writer with his problem. A long conference ensued and the harried operator was given a detailed description of a C.O.D. strategy that has been used successfully for years.

Experience shows that there are four definite types of set owners who ask for credit even though they know that business is transacted strictly on a C.O.D. basis.

The Careless Type

The writer ran into one of these only a couple of days ago. The TV was a three-way combination Philco. The set owner was a well-to-do elderly lady. The home was on the outer fringe of the service area. There was no audio, a weak picture, and slight vertical foldover.

A new 12BH7 vertical-output amplifier fixed the vertical foldover. A new 12AV7 perked up the picture, but that's all tubes would do: the audio still remained silent. The r.f. chassis was pulled out of the cabinet and the audio section inspected. Visually a slightly charred resistor was spotted. It was the "B+" dropping resistor in series with the screen of the 6AU6 audio i.f. (see Fig. 1). The ohmmeter read it as 6000 ohms instead of its called - for 25,000 ohms. It was replaced.

The chassis was hooked up and the TV turned on, still no audio. Evidently something else had burned up the resistor. A screen-to-ground resistance reading was taken. The meter read 4000 ohms. The schematic (Fig. 1) showed a 22,000-ohm resistor to ground and, in parallel with the resistor, was the power supply through the new 25,000-ohm resistor. The meter should have read no less than 10,000 ohms under these circumstances. The 22,000-ohm unit was disconnected. It was the culprit. It read 4000 ohms.

The "B+" dropping resistor had been electrocuted because the 22,000-ohm unit had shorted down, thus dragging a lot of current through both units.

The r.f. chassis was replaced and the audio sounded off. However, the damper was also replaced for arcing. The bill was unavoidably high. When the little old lady received the bill she said helplessly, "All I have home is five dollars. Whatever are we going to do?"

The writer carried out the strategy for the "careless" type. He collected the five and marked on the receipt the balance due. Under that sum he printed in large letters. "WILL MAIL IN 48 HOURS" and had her sign beneath it. He gave her the carbon. Then he handed her a stamped, addressed envelope and smilingly instructed her simply to put the cash, check, or money order in the envelope and drop it in the mailbox.

The click-click efficiency and tactful concern over the unpaid balance worked as it usually does. A check arrived. the next morning. For these people who are simply careless enough not to have enough money around to meet their daily requirements, the collection message must be brought home strongly but not offensively. The readied envelope eliminates the obstacle of the customer having to make one up, and the signature imparts a strong sense of obligation and urgency. In the great majority of cases, the money arrives in the mail quickly.

The Suspicious Type

A second type of individual who asks for credit under all circumstances are those people with suspicious natures. They feel that if they can hold back payment for a length of time they have a weapon by which they can force a TV technician to stand behind his work. The suspicious types are hard nuts to collect from, but it can be done. The technician has the job of instilling enough confidence in the customer to enable him to waive his hard rule of holding back payment.

A perfect "suspicious" type lugged his receiver into the shop the other day. He left his name, address, and telephone number and departed. After the set was repaired, the customer was called and arrived promptly.

He tried to pick up the TV but was handed the bill first. He said, "I'll mail the money in." When reminded of the shop's C.O.D. policy he blurted, "If the set works okay for a while you'll get your money; don't worry."

The writer tactfully went all through the facts that the work is guaranteed, that the company is bonded, and that even though the bill were paid the guarantee would be just as good. The gent stood firm. Since the TV was still in the shop, there was no problem - possession is "nine tenths!" However, insistence would have meant irritation and the loss of good will. The writer went into the strategy for suspicious customers.

"Sir," he said slowly, "You are going to mess up our bookkeeping by holding back the money." He took off his wrist watch. "If you don't trust me sir, here is my wrist watch. When you are satisfied with the repair you can bring it back."

The beefy fellow lost all his belligerency, paid the bill, shook hands amicably, and left with his set. This wrist watch has been offered many times - it has never been accepted yet.

The Professional Beat

Unfortunately there is a small percentage of people who believe that the word "credit" is synonymous with "free gift." They feel that if any firm is fool enough to give them an open account, that firm will just have to suffer the consequences.
A TV technician can spot these professional "beats"; they all tip their hand with the same routine. They do not mention a word about payment until the technician has fully completed his work. Then, after all the screws are back, the set is perking nicely, and the tool box is closed tight, they say, "I don't have no money."

The writer's outfit has a strategy reserved for this set of circumstances. It was used recently by one of the outside men. All of these outside men carry with them copies of a certain type of contract - an impressive looking legal paper - known as a "cognovit note." It is used only in extreme cases where it is obvious that the intentions of the customer are not honest. A copy of this document is shown in Fig.  2.

Fig. 2 - Those who appeal for credit with dishonorable intentions usually can be discouraged with the stringent legal form shown here.

Honest Embarrassment

The fourth type of credit-seeking customer is one who honestly doesn't have the money to pay his bill. There is a method to extend these people a form of credit and practically eliminate all risks.

The writer used it this week on a 16" Emerson repair. One of the field men pulled it into the shop for lack of horizontal sweep. There was a bright, jagged stream of light that extended top to bottom on the screen. A schematic was pulled and troubleshooting started.

The horizontal circuits were examined first. They passed all resistance, voltage, and waveform tests. The trouble seemed to be somewhere past the horizontal output amplifier. The yoke and high voltage transformer were checked by tacking in new replacements. The new replacements didn't change the trouble in the slightest. All the components in the damper circuit were checked; every part was good. This one was weird.

The boosted "B+" was investigated. Everything checked satisfactorily. The only circuit that was left that could possibly cause this condition was the power supply. The schematic was perused to find a clue. It revealed there was an isolated filament winding in the low-voltage transformer for the damper. That is, it was supposed to be isolated.

A resistance check showed there was an 800-ohm short from this winding to ground. The transformer had to be replaced.

The bill was high. The set owner, after hearing the sad news said, "It's going to take me a month to pay the bill." Then he asked, "Is there any way I can get the set now?"

The set owner was asked if he had a checking account. He answered yes. The customer was then instructed to make out a check. He was informed that the check would be held a month before cashing it. All he had to do was cover the check by the time the month had elapsed.

The TV was then delivered, a check was paid for it, even though the check lay in a drawer for thirty days, and everybody concerned was happy.

It's been a year now since the owner of that three-man organization, mentioned at the beginning of this story, has been on the C.O.D. standard. Actual results show it has been a wise move. In comparison to the previous year's $1200 in delinquent accounts, this year's record didn't reach fifty dollars, and these few lost dollars can be directly traced to professional beats.

The volume of calls has increased. The owner attributes part of the increase to the "no-credit" policy. First of all, he claims that he has gained customers because he no longer loses his clientele by having to hound them for money. Also, he no longer loses clientele because they are ashamed to call him when they owe him money.

The fact that a TV service outfit is on the C.O.D. standard doesn't mean there are no longer any forms of credit. An outfit must bend a little to cater to the few inevitable requests. But each request will fall into one or overlap into a couple of the four types noted. If a TV company is prepared with stamped envelopes, a bit of dramatic salesmanship, official cognovit notes, or the holding check gimmick, the credit requests can mostly be satisfied without a loss of customers.

Posted December 23, 2013