January 1933 Radio-Craft
Wax nostalgic about and learn from the history of early electronics.
See articles from Radio-Craft,
published 1929 - 1953. All copyrights are hereby acknowledged.
If this article had appeared
in the New York Times in the year 2014, its author, Glenn Ellsworth, would
have been labeled a 'Depression Denier!' Don't be confused by the word 'denier,' which
most often prior to about 1999 was used to refer to a type of silver coin or a measure
of fineness of silk cloth. Today, it is seen most often as describing one who would
deny something. 'Denyer' is the alternate spelling used by some authors to avoid
confusion, and since the level of spelling knowledge is so low, most people never
notice. But, I digress. The reason I bring up the point is because this article
was published in 1933, little more than three years after the Stock Market Crash
of October 29, 1929 (aka 'Black
Tuesday'). Mr. Ellsworth says in part, "Many service departments are fairly
busy, even with the so-called depression at its height."
His audacity would nowadays earn him pariah status and negate any value his work
might otherwise bring to the science world. As long as I'm pointing out contemporary
expectations, I'll also mention that a modern magazine would show the person holding
the tube as wearing a full suit of battle gear including non-asbestos, heat-resistant
welding-type gloves, a UV-impregnable welding helmet, ear plugs, and an emergency
reaction medical and firefighting team standing by with lights flashing on all vehicles.
Isn't is amazing that our ancestors survived long enough to make your and my presence
Blowtorching Tubes to Life
Figure 1 - Blowtorching Tubes to Life
In the April, 1930, issue of Radio-Craft appeared an interesting article by George
Stoneham regarding a baking process in bringing back to a semblance of activity
those tubes which have tungsten filaments.
Mr. Stoneham used a reflector set over an electric heater in his experiments.
In all probability the results obtained are the same as those secured by the author;
however, there are a few drawbacks to the method described by Mr. Stoneham.
Many service departments are fairly busy, even with the so-called depression
at its height and, what with trying to do several men's work, the shop technician
is inclined to forget that he has one or more tubes in the cooker. The continued
heat of the electric stove will melt the cement which holds the glass to the base
and while the cement no doubt will harden again as the tube cools, the cement crystallizes,
with the result that a slight strain will break it. Another drawback of the baking
process is that the tube cannot be watched during the operation.
A description of the procedure and results of experiments in our shop, with all
the later tube models, both heater and filament types, may be of interest to other
After having recorded the tube characteristics, subject the tube to the slow
heat of a blowtorch, as shown in Fig. 1. (The torch illustrated is a Ratco
part No. 4061; the 4 in. flame will reach a heat of over 2,000 deg. F.) Hold the
tube two or three inches from the point of the flame and revolve the tube slowly.
Bring the "patient" closer and closer to the flame, until the flame comes in
contact with the glass, and keep the tube in this position until the silvery deposit
on the interior of the glass envelope has been driven off.
The operator will notice that within a second or two from the time of contact
with the flame a round spot which is clear of the deposit will appear inside the
tube; the best results will be secured by following the deposit with the flame and
driving it from the glass of the tube itself. Finally, place the tube in a location
where it may be permitted to cool slowly and without chilling.
The cooling process finished, place the tube in the tester and compare the present
readings with those taken before the operation; then put them in a set and compare
the performance with that of a "known" new tube. The results will be very gratifying;
in fact, this procedure may even be tried on a new tube that does not quite come
up to standards of an individual service department, with surprising results.
This reactivation process has been applied to the following tube types: the '24,
'30, '31, '27, '26, '71, '45, '47 and '51. In fact, we are using in a short-wave
receiver a set of '30's, '31's and a '32 which had been thrown into the junk box
as of no further use but which, when reactivated by the blowtorch method, came to
life in great shape and are still' doing service comparable with that of new tubes,
after seven months of continued use.
Our best results were obtained from tubes that showed a heavy deposit on the
inside of the glass, while tubes having very little of the deposit generally did
not react to the treatment. The proportion of cures to incurables is about 80%;
about 20% were quite beyond recall from the limbo of defunct "valves."
It has been brought to the attention of the writer that one experimenter has
found that the glass may melt when using the baking process; probably the tubes
were exposed to a temperature greater than 3,700 deg. F. In using the torch, the
tube is constantly under the eye of the attendant and as soon as the deposit leaves
the surface of the glass, the flame is directed to another portion of the envelope.
This same technician has reported that tube noise had increased after reactivation.
The chances are that noise would have been experienced anyway, due to looseness
of the elements which will be found at times even in some of the best known brands,
however, we have not found any trouble in this respect.
In our service work we have picked up a goodly number of extra dollars by availing
ourselves of this "kink." A nominal fee of 35c per tube is charged and the customer
figures that we are pretty good Service Men to do business with, since we have not
stuck him for the price of new tubes; also, he figures that we must know "our stuff"
to be able to offer him this unusual service, and he passes the good word along
to his friends. Of course, it is not advisable to discourage potential sales of
new tubes, but this stunt is a mighty handy "ace" for use in many instances where
time, money or some other factor is of importance.
Posted November 6, 2020
(updated from original post on 1/16/2015)