RF test engineer Joe Cahak, owner of Sunshine Design Engineering Services, recently had
a photovoltaic panel system installed on his southern California home. After much research and
running through return on investment (RoI) calculations, he made the decision to invest in a
state-of-the-art system by Semper Solaris in San Diego. If you have not looked into modern PV
technology, you might be surprised - as was I - to learn that rather than all the panels feeding
their DC outputs into a common AC inverter that handles phasing issues with the street service,
instead each panel has its own inverter and phase matching circuit so everything simply feeds
into a 2-pole circuit breaker. Doing so eliminates single point failures and allows graceful
degradation if necessary rather than taking down the entire system. Joe has provided a very
nicely done write-up on the system and its installation.See list
of all of Joe's articles at bottom of page.
Solace in Solar
By Joseph L. Cahak
Copyright 2013 Sunshine Design Engineering Services
myself a conservative investor and also a practical environmentalist. I have watched alternative
energy and especially solar for many years and closely looked at the technology, the lifetime,
the efficiency and the economics of various incarnations of solar systems. I also looked at
methane and wind power as possibilities. None quite fit the bill as easy and low maintenance,
I finally made the decision to purchase a system after many years of looking.
We decided to go with a company called Semper Solaris in San Diego, CA. They serve the entire
Southern California area. So why did I purchase a solar system now and what did I get? Why did
I go with the vendor I did?
In order for me to give a bit of perspective on the solar
topic, please bear with a quasi-historical review. In the early days it was 12 or 48VDC lead
acid batteries and single inverters and high DC losses between the solar cells and the batteries.
The batteries were expensive, heavy, dangerous and prone to failure with regular replacement
costs. The systems were OK for small scale and/or emergency use, but not cost effective for
total home power systems. The solar panel glazing and solar cells did not hold up well in the
sun. The solar cells also suffered high temperature power output loss. The DC line losses are
very prohibitive as is the battery losses and expense.
Another reason working against
the solar system cost and maintenance was the competing lower cost of the grid. In California
the cost of power was already very high. The last few years we have had power deregulation and
other stupid politics and energy gaming schemes with the big energy and power companies colluding
to set high prices. The rates are due to go up a minimum of 6-8% per year for many years to
come. In addition, recently Edison Electric and SDG&E decided to shut down San Onofrae nuclear
reactor. They are working to try to make us rate payers pay for the failed generator. So rates
will really jump. Estimates range from 30-40% in addition to the 6-8%/ year projected increases.
This makes solar very attractive for southern California and Arizona. In addition the minimum
electric price is $5 per month and SDG&E is expected to raise it to either $10/month or
$50/month. We are waiting to find out. Reviewing my SDG&E bill I see they now charge me
$65 for electric generation, $3.48 DWR bond charge, $65.81 distribution and $1.88 Competition
Transition Charge. I find it interesting that they want so much more for distribution. These
charges sound excessive to me.
Where we live in central San Diego County it gets very
hot in the summer and Air Conditioning is critical. We minimize it as much as we can, but with
tiered rates, we pay a minimum of $0.17/KWh. We can pay of $0.35/KWh when using more than 597
KWh. This coincides with the high heat of summer. This adds up to steep costs very quickly.
Now the AC will run the most while we produce the most solar power mid day summer. The panels
are have an aspect ratio sized for maximum output when the heat load on the house is highest
through the spring, summer and fall. In addition the tax incentives for Solar power are lapsing
after Dec. 31st this year. Even with this loss on credit, solar will still be a viable electric
rate investment given the increases coming.
The Solar Cells in the early years were only
about 6-8% efficient at best and they did not hold up well under heat and intense sun. The contacts
also did not always adhere well. They also were prone to corrosion around the contacts. The
newer solar cells are larger, have good heat resistance and lifetime. The single crystal cells
have higher efficiency than the cheap poly-silicon cells so prevalent in the market today. The
efficiency of our panels is 14.8%. The implant and surface finish holds up to the heat and sun
better than previously and has a highly rated lifetime warranty. They also have better grids
and interconnects for longer life. Solar World encapsulates the cells and contacts in a moisture
proof hermetic seal.
Many solar panels are not built well and can have the glazing cloud
and crack after time; some of them get moisture inside easily and fail to shed it well to keep
the panels working best. Some panels are not built to last for the long haul. The Solar Panels
we got are from Solar World. They are US made and of the highest quality and have a 25 year
warranty. They are solidly built of all aluminum frame and solid corners. The panels are clear
covered with a moisture and environmental seal and backed with a white solar resistant material
and then the glazing sits on the panels to help with heat transfer and lower reflective loss,
all very lightweight and strong. I was told I could stand on the panels even in the center.
Figure 1 - Solar World Panel
Figure 2 - Solar Panel Grid and Corner
Figure 3 - Solar Panel Rear Electric Connection
A few years ago, Enphase Energy developed
what is now known as the micro inverter. The Micro Inverters have changed the alternate energy
market completely. With the micro inverters, the DC from the solar panel is converted in small
inverters at the solar panel to AC for feed into the home AC entry panel. All that was needed
was some Quad20Amp breakers to the 240/208 VAC AC feed panel.
The solar system uses Enphase
Micro Inverters model M215 and has one inverter for each panel. This has several advantages.
Each panel puts out it individual maximum output to the inverter which converts to 240V AC and
is synchronously feed back into the utility grid. This gives the lowest line losses to the AC
Line Power. Batteries are no longer used, as the power grid becomes the backup system. You are
merely adding power back and getting credit up to the amount of electricity you use over the
year above what you produced. You typically will not make money from the utility in California.
The power companies have strong agreements and regulations in their favor. So the strategy is
to make enough power to almost cover your maximum average total power. Our system should produce >
95% of or Electric use today. One final feature of the micro inverters is that if one or more
panels lose some or all power due to shade, the loss only affects the shaded panels. All other
panels will still produce all that they can or not. The synchronous inverter detects the frequency
and phase of the grid electric feed and synchronously inverts and steps up the VDC input to
the 240VAC output to match the line characteristics and the added phase needed to produce instead
of use power.
Figure 4 - Enphase Micro Inverter Top
Figure 5 - Enphase Micro Inverter Bottom
The Enphase units each report to an Envoy Communications Gateway. We log in through
a web portal and can monitor our panels’ output, status and contact support when needed.
The Solar power feeds into most 200 AMP home panels. They just feed in thru breakers. This
saves a huge amount on panel replacement.
Figure 6 - Quad Pak Panel Breaker
Figure 7 - Electric Panel Labeling
When the installation crew worked the roof for the installation mounts, they discovered
a bit of roof damage and the old roofing paper was dried to powder. So we had to add about $2400
for a section of roof repair. They fixed two leaks in the process. We weren’t thrilled about
the added cost, but expected it.
Final System looks great and has a low profile that
is not visible from the front of the house.
Figure 8 - Complete Solar Installation
Figure 9 - Side View with Gap Above Roof Tiles
Figure 10 - Solar Panel Close-Up
Figure 11 - Solar Panels After Tree TrimmingVendor
talked to and looked at many of the solar systems and finance agreements over the years, but
just never saw one that had all I was looking for. Then I gave a call to Semper Solaris after
seeing an ad in the paper. Semper Solaris is a local company and one of the founders was a marine.
We met Mike, one of the salesmen and he explained the system and I liked all the features and
warranty. The finance terms are all fine for many people in different income situations. I was
just getting back to work, but had some saving to invest in the right things. So I asked about
cash discount and got an 8% savings on the total for paying with cash. This investment of $21K
would "earn" me about $170-300 a month for the next 25 years. Sounds like a good retirement
investment to me. Certainly better return than I was getting for savings.
One note on
leased solar system is that is may impact your ability to sell or the sale-ability of your home.
Some of the leases and systems may not be attractive to prospective buyers and it may greatly
limit your range of buyers.Solar System
20 panels rated at 245
watts each for a total full power ~3.5-5kWh for about 600-1000kWh/month or an annual average
of 740kWh/month. The panels have a rated module efficiency of 14.8%.
We are using about
742kWh/month annual average presently. Our house is about 1800 Sq Ft and we live in central
San Diego County. So our highest cost utilities are the water well pump, the freezer, refrigerator
and the Air Conditioner/Furnace. The solar system was estimated generate about >96% of our
total electric usage.
As I write this, on a sunny November day, 6 weeks from solar minimum,
we are getting 26 kWh/Day from the system. With some quick estimates for the solar min and max
output, one can approximate of 20-35 kWh/day for a monthly output range of 600-1000 kWh. At
this day’s output of 26KWh, if we had a full 30 days of sun, would equate to 770 kWh/month output.
This output in fall at the beginning of November sun season is a very good sign to start with.
We’ll be watching to see how things stack up when the days get cloudy as well to see the impact
to the overall total collected. The overage also accommodates the cloudy days to keep the average
at better than 700kWh/month.
The roof has an aspect angle of 30 degrees. The sun ranges
here in San Diego County between 33.5 and 80.5 degrees. So a 30 slope means it is perpendicular
to a 60 degree sun. This puts sun max collected in the spring (~April 15th) and fall (~Sept
15th). Our hottest days are in July-October so the aspect is well suited for this.
gave them a cleaning after 3 weeks. We have horses and live in a dry, windy and dusty area,
so they build up dust in the dew laden mornings. I used some light dish soap and a half cup
of white vinegar to cut mineral deposits with city water. I found a great 16 ft variable length
rod and brush/squeegee and wide bucket to the cleaning and wiping dry. Home Depot had pretty
good deals on them. I saw about a 200-300 Watt bump in power output after the cleaning.
The total system cost was $21,200 after 8% off for cash discount
with $2400 roof repair and $6500 tax credits yields $17,100 net costReturn
Notes on Permits
- The ROI for 17,100 at today’s electric rate is $2500 for a payback period of 6.8 years.
- The ROI for 17,100 at next year’s rate is $3500 for a payback period of 4.8 years.
- The earning after the system is paid off is $3500 per year. So the income from the loss
offset is between 14.8 to 20.5% annually or about $208-$290/month. Not too bad an investment.
- Not to be forgotten is the property value increase with an owned system on the house.
I figure the house value could have increased by at least $30K.
- San Diego County Building Permit was obtained after the system was drafted and documented.
- San Diego County then performed an on-site inspection to approve the building changes.
- SDG&E Permit To Operate - for solar power hook up and right to operate
We give Semper Solaris a 5 star rating. They
were professional in the sales and explanations of the deals and system. Mike was real upfront
about everything and provided me with follow up materials to share with this article. I was
told the serve the entire Southern California area: San Diego, Temecula and Murrieta.
If this interests you, call them and ask for Mike Barnett, tell them Joe sent you. Mike has
given me his word of special deals for all referrals. Semper
CA licensed General Building Contractor:
1637 Tierra Montanosa
Alpine, CA 91901
Posted November 5, 2013
Sunshine Design Engineering Services is located in the sunny San Vicente Valley
near San Diego, CA, gateway to the mountains and skies. Are you looking for new things to design,
program or create and need assistance? I offer design services with specialties in electronic hardware,
CAD and software engineering, and 25 years of experience with Test Engineering services in RF/microwave,
transceiver and semiconductor parametric test, test application program development, automation
programs, database programming, graphics and analysis, and mathematical algorithms.
||- Searching for the Q
Noise and Noise Measurements
Solace in Solar
Device Input Parameters
with Vector Analysis
- Computing with Scattering Parameters
- Measurements with Scattering Parameters
- Ponderings on Power Measurements
Scattered Thoughts on Scattering Parameters
|Sunshine Design Engineering Services
23517 Carmena Rd
Featuring: Test Automation Services, RF Calculator and S-Parameter
Library (DLL & LLB)