June 1931 Radio-Craft
Wax nostalgic about and learn from the history of early electronics.
See articles from Radio-Craft,
published 1929 - 1953. All copyrights are hereby acknowledged.
This reactance measuring bridge circuit employs a very unique element for generating an alternating current: an electromechanical buzzer which doubles as an audio source. Sure, it doesn't produce a pure sinewave, but for the method used here to determine inductance and capacitance it does not matter. Rather than attempting to measure an absolute value of inductance or capacitance, a known reactance is used as part of a balanced bridge. This is by no means a precision instrument since accuracy depends on the user's interpretation of the presence or absence of an audible 'buzz' in a pair of headphones, but in an era when 'real' test equipment was beyond the budgets of many (maybe most) hobbyists, the scheme was better than nothing at all.
Measuring Inductance and Capacity
How the Experimenter May Utilize a Reactance Bridge
By James A. Dowie*
In the February issue of Radio-Craft appeared a description of the construction of a Wheatstone bridge which could be used to measure unknown resistances, such as are used in radio work. ("A Home-Made Slide-Wire Bridge," by A. W, Bonser, page 482). The object of this article is to show how the Wheatstone bridge may be used also to good advantage by radio-tricians and Service Men for making various measurements of inductance and capacity - two important factors necessary for satisfactory reception of radio signals. Inductances, as used in radio work, function under alternating current; therefore, measurements should be carried out with alternating current.
Fig. 1 - The simple bridge, with buzzer and phones, for measurement of inductance.
Fig. 1 shows the circuit arrangement used in this bridge. In series with the battery "B," a buzzer is placed; and the combination is utilized to give an alternating current through the various arms of the bridge. (A high-frequency buzzer or a vacuum-tube A.F. oscillator, such as have been described in Radio-Craft, may also be used for this purpose.) With this arrangement a pair of phones serves as the indicating device; they are connected as shown in the diagram. If audio-frequency current flows through the phones, a sound will be heard; while, if no alternating current flows, no sound is heard. The Wheatstone bridge is then balanced by sliding the contact c over the arms m, n of the bridge until a minimum of sound is heard; this is the condition of balance.
(Note: "Minimum" sound is specified; because it may be impossible to obtain a zero sound-balance with this apparatus, on account of induction and stray capacity effects. Knowing this, we will now consider the case of measuring the inductance of a coil by means of such an arrangement.).
Measurement of Inductance
In the circuit arrangement of this bridge used for inductance measurements, m and n are the slide-arms of the bridge; c is the sliding contact; L the known inductance, and X is an unknown coil whose inductance is to be measured.
This circuit is in theory the same as that used in the resistance measurement, described in the preceding article; when the slider c is moved along m and n until a balance is obtained, a minimum sound will he heard in the telephones. Then the following relation is true:
Thus, if a single standard inductance L and a slide-wire bridge with phones, battery and buzzer are available, the values of unknown inductances may be easily measured.
This relationship is only true in practice when the unknown inductance X is of the same order of magnitude as the standard inductance L. By this it is meant that inaccuracies will arise in these measurements if the standard inductance is about 0.1 millihenry, for instance, while the unknown inductance is 10 millihenries; because the ratio of m to n would then be too great to obtain an accurate balance. If the ratio of m and n is about 1 or 2, then a sharp balance will be had.
The following notes should be of interest to radio-tricians interested in accurate measurements with a bridge:
The formula given above for inductance is sufficiently accurate for all practical purposes; however, it does not take into consideration the resistance of the inductance coils. If there is a great discrepancy between the resistances of the two coils L and X, it is quite possible that a sharp balance will not he obtained. Balancing a Wheatstone bridge circuit is something like tuning a radio receiving circuit; since resistance in a resonant radio circuit makes for extremely broad tuning.
Balancing a Wheatstone bridge is equivalent to reducing the resistance, and thus enables sharp balance or tuning. If the resistances of the coils are not balanced, a sharp balance will not be secured and, therefore, the accuracy of the measurement will be destroyed; since the accuracy of the measurement in a Wheatstone bridge depends upon the sharpness of the balance.
Correction for Resistance
Since all inductance coils have some resistance, a better arrangement of the bridge is shown in Fig. 2, where each coil has its compensating resistance (R3, R4) in series.
For precision measurements, it is necessary to strike a balance for both the inductances and the resistances of the coils. The inductance balance is secured by means of the buzzer and headphones; while the resistance balance is secured by a voltmeter and the battery B2 for the source of supply. In this bridge, Fig. 2, we use two double-pole double-throw switches (S1 and S2); one is used for switching on either the voltmeter V or the phones PH for the balance indicator. (The potentials of B1 and B2 must be found by experiment).
The buzzer and phones are used for the A.C. inductance balance, with switches S1, S2 thrown left; the battery and voltmeter, for securing a D.C. resistance balance, the switches thrown right. The variable resistors, R3, R4, placed in series with each of the inductances enable us to balance the inductance arms for resistance.
Fig. 2 - The bridge arrangement for balancing inductance and resistance to obtain a true reading of the former.
The following gives the method used for operating this type of bridge circuit. First, a balance is obtained for the A.C. signal; the double-pole, double-throw switches are both thrown to the left, to use the buzzer and phones. The sliding contact c on the wire m-n is varied until a balance is obtained. The switches are then thrown to the right to place the battery and voltmeter in the circuit. With the sliding contact c fixed at the position previously obtained, vary the resistance of R3 and R4 until the voltmeter v indicates a balance, by zero deflection. Now switch over again to the buzzer and phones, and vary the position of the sliding contact until a balance is obtained, as indicated by a minimum sound in the phones. Again switch back to battery and voltmeter, keeping the sliding contact c fixed in the new position previously found; and very the resistors R3 and R4 until a balance is obtained. Alternate this way until a very sharp balance is obtained on both D.C. and A.C. - then note the values of m and n and apply the formula previously given.
It will be noted that the important adjustment of the sliding contact c was not changed in balancing the resistances of R3 and R4; since the important adjustment of the slider determines the inductance measurement. The above formula is absolutely correct and is based upon both types of balance thus obtained.
Measurement of Capacity
The Wheatstone slide-wire bridge may be used also to measure unknown capacities, there being required in this circuit but one known capacity. Fig. 3 illustrates the connections for this bridge; in which C is the known capacity and CX the unknown capacity, while m and n are the lengths of the two arms of the slide-wire, which are adjusted for a balance by a minimum sound in the phones.
Fig. 3 - Use of the bridge for capacity measurements, with the necessary compensation for zero setting.
It is evident that, with this arrangement, the resistance in one arm of the bridge is balanced against the impedance of the condenser in the adjacent arm. (The impedance of a condenser is the resultant of resistance and reactance but, as the resistance is so very low, compared to the reactance, it can be disregarded and the entire impedance considered as reactance.)
The reactance of a condenser varies inversely as its capacity; while the reactance of an inductance varies directly, and therefore the preceding formula must be rewritten and used in the following form:
For example, the scale has 100 divisions and the sound is minimum in the phones at a point on the wire 25 divisions from E (Fig. 6); leaving 75 divisions for n, between F and c. Assuming that we use a standard capacity value of 0.002-mf. for C, we may substitute these values, giving
In all these measurements using a buzzer to supply the alternating current to the bridge, it is advisable to set the buzzer at some distance from the bridge, or muffle it in some wav; for otherwise it will be difficult to determine whether the sound is coming from the phones and due to the current passing through them, or whether it is direct noise from the buzzer. (A "high-frequency" buzzer is more quiet. See Fig. 4.)
Fig. 4 - The circuit connections of a Wheatstone bridge using a high-frequency buzzer, for accurate measurements of capacity.
An excellent source of A.C. voltage for measuring inductance and capacity is a vacuum-tube audio-frequency oscillator which does not have the above-mentioned fault of buzzers. The terminals of the oscillator are connected to the points E arid F of the bridge. (See Fig. 5) Resistor R1 controls the amount of A.C. fed to the bridge.
In these measurements, a calibrated variable (air dielectric) condenser may be used as the standard C; with this, a very large range of unknown capacities may be very simply measured.
First, the slider is set at the mid-point of the length of resistance wire, thus making m equal to n. The variable condenser C is then adjusted until a balance is obtained. Then, the dial reading of the standard condenser C will indicate the capacity of the unknown condenser CX; since m and n are equal.
Fig. 5 - The most satisfactory operation of the bridge is obtained with an A.C. oscillator giving a good note.
A midget condenser, C1, is necessary in this measurement so that a balance (at the minimum capacity of C) may be had, and the zero reading of C taken without the unknown condenser CX in the circuit. It is required also to bring the balance point further up the scale on C when measuring small values of CX.
The effective resistance of the condensers enters into the measurement of capacities exactly as in the measurement of inductances; but, in the case of condensers using air as the dielectric, this is not very important because the resistance of such condensers is almost zero. However, where condensers have different dielectrics, (for instance, air, and "mud" compositions), there will be a considerable difference in their resistances; which means that it will be impossible to get a silent point in the telephones. However, a fair balance point can usually be secured.
Fig. 6 - A wooden base, 8 x 45 inches, will mount a one-meter rule as shown; or the "reciprocal" scale of the February article may be used.
Because of the insulating properties of condensers, the circuit will be open; therefore, it is impossible to balance this bridge with direct current. However, a good balance, with fair accuracy, is generally found when using the fundamental circuit shown in Fig. 3.
In order ·to secure a more accurate balance with this bridge, it is necessary to connect a variable resistor R in one or the other of the condenser arms, (X1 or X2, Fig. 3.); the proper place is found by trial. This will compensate for any resistance effect introduced by the condenser in the other condenser arm. The readings of this resistance, with and without the condenser CX, are indicative of the losses in the condenser under test. This is a check-up of "leaky" condensers.
Construction of a Slide-Wire Bridge
The connections between the components of the bridge are made on the top of the wooden base by means of brass straps 1 1/2 inches wide and 1/4-inch thick (Shown in Fig. 6.). The holes for the terminals are tapped the correct size.
The wire used for m and n may be of any standard make of resistance wire (such as nichrome, German silver, constantin, etc.) and its gauge from No. 24 to No. 28 B & S.; as these are the most convenient sizes with which to work. (Note: Be careful to secure uniform wire, for the resistances of the two arms of the bridge m and n are proportional to their lengths only if their cross sections are equal.)
The resistance wire is stretched taut almost flat on the board, and securely fastened at E and F to the brass strap at each end of the bridge. The meter-scale is mounted directly beneath the resistance wire, thus positioning the slide-wire about 1/16-in. above the meter-scale. The contact slider c may be one of the sharp edges of a 1/4-in. brass rod; the opposite edge being soldered to a length of rubber-covered lamp cord. Compare Fig. 6 with Fig. 2.
* Chief Instructor, National Radio Institute
Posted August 25, 2015