October 1960 Electronics World
[Table of Contents]
People old and young enjoy waxing nostalgic about and learning some of the history of early electronics.
Electronics World was published from May 1959 through December 1971.
As time permits, I will be glad to scan articles for you. All copyrights
(if any) are hereby acknowledged.
Capacitors come in a huge variety of package configurations, chemical makeups, physical constructions and sizes, capacitance values, and voltage and power handling abilities. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses for a particular application. When capacitors are functioning properly, life is great, but when one decides to fail either completely or partially, troubleshooting the cause can be a real challenge. The best kind of electrical component failure from a troubleshooting perspective is one where the component releases its life-giving internal smoke and in the process leaving a clearly visible clue like a cracked case or a nice black mark when none should be. Otherwise, the job can get interesting. Being proficient at schematic reading and tracing waveforms through circuits is a real benefit, but that option is not always available, as in the case of undocumented equipment. In that situation, experience and intuition might be your only hope. This article gives some pointers that can put another method or two in your collective bag of tricks.
See all the available Electronics World articles.
Wayward Capacitor Woes
By Allan F. Kinckiner
Fig. 1 - Sensitive capacitor leakage measurement.
Fig. 2. - Preamp in which noise was generated by a "good" ceramic capacitor.
Look out for "perfectly good" capacitors that pass all tests but produce strange and confusing faults.
Every technician is confronted at one time or another by tubes that pass every test on the very best tube checkers but simply will not work properly in certain circuits, although a substituted tube will. After a number of such experiences, the technician adopts the following credo: If a tube is suspected, don't rely on a check-substitute.
Another electronic component that often presents the same baffling condition of causing circuit malfunction while passing every test is our friend the capacitor. A look at what tests these components are subjected to in the better capacitor analyzers reveals the following: capacitance measurement (generally quite accurate) and leakage (the amount of direct current the component will pass). In the latter check, a substantial d.c. voltage is fed into one terminal of the component, which is in series with a voltage-reading meter. Some analyzers use eye tubes or neon bulbs in place of the meter.
A more efficient leakage test is to use a source of several hundred volts (depending on the component's rating) applied to one terminal of the capacitor, which is series-connected to a v.t.v.m., as in Fig. 1. Leakage resistance may then be determined from the following relationship: Rc/Rm = Ec/Em; where Rc is the leakage resistance of the capacitor, Rm the input d.c. resistance of the v.t.v.m. (usually 11 megohms), Ec is the voltage across the capacitor, and Em is the voltage read on the meter.
In the example shown, the meter reading (Em.) is .1 volt, which leaves 299.9 volts as Ec. Solving for Rc, we we have a leakage resistance of almost 33,000 megohms. The leakage current, determined by Ohm's Law, would come to less than a hundredth of a microampere. Insignificant as these leakage figures seem, there are circuits in which capacitor replacement would be warranted.
The advantages of checking leakage in this way are twofold. First, the sensitivity is greater than in the test provided by most analyzers. In the second place, leakage is more easily read. A man could get eyestrain trying to judge the opening or closing of an eye tube or the lighting of a neon lamp. However, just as the tube checker should be neither condemned nor scrapped because it doesn't bat one thousand, the capacitor analyzer should not be demoted for its less-than-perfect score on the leakage test.
It is true that the substitution of a suspected capacitor is not so easily accomplished as that of a tube. Yet this will often be the quickest path to a repair. However, the substitution should only be considered after thorough circuit testing has left the capacitor as the prime suspect, although on circumstantial evidence. The capacitor fault may be so elusive that it will not always be possible to, determine exactly what defect has occurred, although malfunction disappears when a substitution is made. Following are several accounts of skirmishes with capacitors, to prove the points made.
Before going into the case histories, we should like to point out another parallel between tubes and capacitors. The baffling defects are most likely to occur in more critical electronic circuits, such as low-level amplifiers, discriminating or limiting networks (such as the sync stages), sine and other waveform generators (such as TV deflection generators), and in other pulse-handling or pulse-forming circuits.
The Sizzling Ceramic
A V-M model 711 tape recorder came in for service with the complaint of being noisy. Inspection revealed that, with no tape threaded on and with the "play" button depressed, a constant sizzling noise could be heard. The latter could be attenuated by adjusting the volume control, indicating that the trouble was in a preceding stage (or perhaps in a later stage, but was being detected by the sensitive preamplifier). A scope check quickly eliminated the alternate possibility in this instance.
The preamplifier consisted of a 12A-X7 with the triodes in cascade (see Fig. 2.) Further troubleshooting revealed that grounding the second grid killed the noise, but grounding the first grid had no effect. The sizzling noise sounded precisely like a noisy resistor, so the resistors were substituted after resistance and voltage checks in the order numbered, but without any result.
Capacitor Cx was disconnected at the second grid and checked with an analyzer, which passed it as being faultless. Cx was also checked as per the technique discussed in connection with Fig, 1; not the slightest leakage was indicated. Since every other component in the circuit had been substituted, Cx was now temporarily replaced with a tacked-in unit, and dawg-gone if that didn't cure the trouble.
This capacitor, a black .01-μf. disc ceramic, subjected to all types of further testing on our brand X capacitor analyzer, was also checked on a fellow service technician's brand Y analyzer. It passed without even the slightest indication of fault.
Fig. 3. - Low (A, top) and proper (B, bottom) sinewave height in Synchroguide waveform.
Fig. 4. - Low (A. top) and proper (B, bottom) sine-wave height in multivibrator waveform.
A TV set came in with the complaint that raster height was insufficient, with the compression occurring on the bottom. The condition occurred only after the receiver had been operating an hour or more, and would get progressively worse. After the saw-tooth forming capacitor in the vertical circuit had been replaced, the bottom of the raster was easily stretched out to fill the bottom of the CRT screen with normal linearity. Furthermore, the raster remained constant in vertical size, without needing later readjustment.
The capacitors that produce the not uncommon defect noted here are generally of the waxed paper type. Their capacitance may tend to increase as their temperature goes up. While a capacitor analyzer is quite capable of indicating an increase in capacitance, it can do so only if the suspected component is heated to the temperature at which it works in the receiver. Thus, tacking in a replacement is the quickest way to make a satisfactory check.
The horizontal Synchroguide circuit is one of those where capacitors can really raise havoc. For example:
The fellow service technician previously referred to as the owner of the brand Y analyzer sought help on a tough dog. It was an RCA KCS34B that would not hold horizontal sync for more than twenty minutes. In answer to questioning, he insisted that he had disconnected and tested all the capacitors in the circuit and that all read up to par on his analyzer. Knowing him to be a thorough technician who normally makes the necessary resistance, voltage, and scope checks when he has trouble, we advised him to tack-solder capacitor substitutions.
About one hour later he phoned with the information that, "after replacing the .002 μf. that feeds the sync and sampling pulses to the grid of the a.f.c. triode (C1 in Fig. 5), the trouble was corrected." While he was happy that he had repaired the set, he was also extremely unhappy because his expensive analyzer would not indicate anything wrong with the replaced unit. The .002-μf. unit was one of those black, plastic-encased capacitors.
In line with this experience involving Synchroguides, one set, an RCA KCS84F, operated relatively normally except that the horizontal sync was critical. It was noticed during troubleshooting that the frequency slug of the oscillator transformer adjusted at an extremely withdrawn position. Component and voltage-checking tests revealed nothing, so the various frequency-determining capacitors were temporarily replaced. When C2 in Fig. 5 was replaced, not only did the frequency slug adjust to a more orthodox position, but the horizontal saw-tooth waveform increased from 130 to over 160 volts, peak-to-peak, as a scope check showed. As a result other improvements occurred; the width increased, as did the high voltage, with improved focusing.
C2 was also a black, plastic-encased tubular; it too passed all tests, including leakage, and its measured capacitance was within ten percent of nominal value although it was only rated at twenty percent. We are not exactly sure what the elusive fault is that occurs in units of this type, but suspect that the pulsed nature of the voltage to which they are subjected causes them to react erratically in a way that does not show up on static tests.
Watch That "Q"
On to case 4: The stabilizing network in the Synchroguide circuit is a tank that generates a sine wave at approximately the horizontal sync frequency. This plays an important role in maintaining synchronization in the presence of random pulses that might otherwise trigger the oscillator falsely. The network consists of an adjustable coil shunted by a capacitor.
In Fig. 5, this network consists of C3 shunted by Lp, with the latter being known as the phasing coil. Stabilizing efficiency is affected by the over-all "Q" of the tank, which is affected by the "Q" of C3 specifically. This factor may decrease over a period of time, reducing sine-wave amplitude.
Analyzers will not indicate this lowered "Q" factor, but it can be determined with the scope. The waveform of Fig. 3A was noted at point C of a Synchroguide used in a '53 Philco. Note that, while the phasing coil is adjusted properly, the sine-wave amplitude is about 15 percent of the composite waveform's total amplitude. The waveform of Fig. 3B was noted at the same point after C3 was changed. Note now that the sine-wave amplitude is nearly 25 percent of the composite amplitude. This change improved horizontal synchronization in this particular receiver considerably.
Fig. 5. - Synchroguide oscillator with sinewave generating tank (Lp and C3).
Fig. 6. - The pointer indicates stain on capacitor case from electrolyte leakage.
In multivibrator-type horizontal oscillators, the stabilizing tank again consists of an adjustable coil (usually called the ringing coil) shunted by a capacitor. The coil's action parallels that of the phasing coil in that it generates a sine wave each time the oscillator plate switches on to draw current. The tank is invariably in series with a resistor in the plate lead of the multi vibrator's controlling (first) triode. The stabilizing efficiency of this network is similar to that of the one in Fig. 5, and similar problems may occur.
The relative "Q" factor of the tank in these circuits can also be determined with the scope. Fig. 4A was taken at the plate of the first triode of a horizontal multivibrator in a Motorola. Note that the amplitude of the sine wave is about 30 percent of the composite waveform's amplitude. Fig. 4B was taken at the same point after the tank's capacitor was changed. Now the sine wave scopes better than 50 percent of the total waveform height. The replacement cleared up a complaint that setting of the horizontal hold control was too critical.
The ratios given here for sine-wave amplitude to overall waveform height are those most often used in original design for Synchroguide and multivibrator circuits, although they are not universal. In general, where marginal horizontal-hold is the problem and no other defects exist, approximating these ratios will produce enough improvement to satisfy an unhappy customer.
The change in the capacitor, over a period of time, that produces this reduction in sine-wave amplitude sheds light on the tendency of older sets to develop more critical-sync.
Capacitor or Rectifier?
A Philco TV about nine years old was benched for drifting vertical lock. The hold control had to be readjusted every ten minutes until it reached the end of its rotation, after which rolling could not be stopped. Trouble of this nature is due to gradual changes in such frequency-determining oscillator components as resistors (including the control), the blocking oscillator transformer, and, of course, the coupling and timing capacitors. In this case, replacing a capacitor corrected the trouble.
Suspected of leakage, the capacitor had been checked on an analyzer but no leakage had been found. When it was checked again after the replacement had worked, there was considerable leakage. Further checking showed that, when the capacitor was connected to the tester in one way, there was still no leakage. However, when the capacitor leads were reversed, leakage was clearly indicated! Evidently the component had begun to act like a semiconductor, passing current in one direction only. It was weird but it happened. The unit was a .01-μf. capacitor encased in plastic.
An Eccentric Electrolytic
The villain in case 6, unlike the smaller units involved with the other histories noted so far, was the big brother of the capacitor family, an electrolytic. A Sylvania TV (Model 540) came in with the complaint that it was erratically blowing a 2.5-ampere fuse. One fuse might last several days; but the next might only survive for one hour.
In a bench check, line current was metered at about 1.5 amperes. Receiver operation was entirely normal, with good picture and sound. Instrument checks revealed no unusual conditions. However a visual check showed a suspicious chemical staining at the metal band used to mount a 150-μf., 200-volt electrolytic filter to the chassis. Unfastening the metal band by removing the self-tapping screw that held it to the chassis caused the line current to fall to about 1 ampere.
Fig. 6 shows the staining on the cardboard case of this unit, with the metal band removed to render the symptom more visible. This type of electrolyte leak-through on cardboard-cased units was more common in prewar radios, where it often led to puzzling hum problems. Service technicians can be grateful that the difficulty doesn't arise so often these days, but they should keep in mind the fact that it can occur. One end of this capacitor was connected directly to one side of the a.c. line in a voltage doubler using two selenium rectifiers, which is why the leakage blew fuses. However, an analyzer would not have indicated abnormal leakage.
Thus we close the file on wayward capacitors. In each of the cases described here, the defects were of the kind that would escape detection with capacitor analyzers or other direct instrument checks. In each, secondary evidence was the only indication that the capacitor might be at fault. In closing, a few words of commendation might be said for that old standby, the oscilloscope. As in several instances recounted here, its role in revealing the secondary conditions that lead to apprehension of guilty capacitors with off-beat defects is important.
Posted March 25, 2014