BSEE seeks career advice - RF Cafe Forums
Because of the high maintenance needed to monitor and filter spammers from the RF Cafe Forums, I decided that it would
be best to just archive the pages to make all the good information posted in the past available for review. It is unfortunate
that the scumbags of the world ruin an otherwise useful venue for people wanting to exchanged useful ideas and views.
It seems that the more formal social media like Facebook pretty much dominate this kind of venue anymore anyway, so if
you would like to post something on RF Cafe's
page, please do.
Below are all of the forum threads, including all
the responses to the original posts.
Post subject: BSEE seeks career advice Posted: Tue Dec 13, 2005 5:34 am
Hi. I graduated from
M.I.T. 2 years ago with a BSEE and a BS in Management. As I was torn between working in EE and business, so I
tried working in business as a management consultant for two years. However, now I really feel the urge to come
back to tinkering with circuits (I used to be an avid electronics hobbyist, and loved to build hobby kits-eg.
Stereo Power Amp, Audio mixer etc. in high school)
So, I took the big leap and quit my business job two
months back, and decided to reaquaint myself with EE. Went back and did all the problem sets to all my undergrad
circuits courses, since I haven't looked at a circuit in two years. I am now looking for an entry-level position
as an analog design engineer/applications engineer, but the market is tough as many newbies like me on this board
attest to. Based on self-study, I have done coursework upto building an op-amp, compensating it etc., but do not
currently have the knowledge of specific areas like high frequency techniques, or building D/A converters, power
electronics ICs etc.
My question is the following:
1) Based on my current knowledge, is there ANY entry
level job I can get in IC design/apps, or do I need to have a lot more knowledge in the field before I can even
get an internship?
2) Is loving to tinker with circuits hands on a good indication that one will like IC
design? My worry is that it appears that a lot simulation is done today with software based design tools, and the
hands-on aspect is minimal.
Any advice you can offer is helpful.
Posted: Tue Dec 13, 2005 5:43 am
To quit a full-time job without having a new one is suicide in these days !
Maybe you will reach something by the help of the name "M.I.T.", but surely not with your BSEE. There's a
big difference between electronic hobbyists and modern IC design.
helloPosted: Tue Dec 13, 2005 2:29 pm
take some course work online
course work in analog IC, digital IC, data converter IC design.
if you can handle MIT or so you say,
berkeley should be a joke for you.
Post subject: ThanksPosted: Wed Dec 14, 2005
This NTU seems like a great idea. btw, I've heard that the courses at UCLA/Berkeley are better in
terms of analog esp. compared to MIT. At MIT, there is so much more research/courses in Comp. Sci and signal
processing (A.I., DSP etc.). Virtually nothing in RFIC at MIT until recently, when one of Thomas Lee's students
became a Asst. Prof. at MIT.
If you had a choice, would you only take a course on RF circuit design, or
would you also through in some material on digital IC design as well? What about antenna deisgn etc.? Thanks for
Post subject: Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2005 8:48 am
If your truly
an MIT grad you should have no problems getting into an entry design position lots of company will do it. Start
sending your resume to compamies.
Post subject: berkeleyPosted: Mon Dec 19, 2005
True, you are an MIT Grad. You should NO PROBLEM getting interviews.
Having said that take
these courses at Berkeley: I know MIT won't have a lot of courses, actually Michael Perrott teaches a high speed
class at MIT and is available on opencourseware: ocw.mit.edu.
Advanced Analog Integrated
Circuits at Berkeley
Advanced Integrated Circuits for Communications at Berkeley
VLSI Interfaces (Data
Conversion) at Berkeley
Those three and you should be all set.
Take Digital Integrated Circuits if
you want too.
Post subject: hiPosted: Mon Dec 19, 2005 4:57 pm
management consulting like ?
Post subject: Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2005 5:47 pm
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 2:02 pm
From your description it looks like you have a good background and a passion for circuit design. As suggested here
you should take these advanced courses, which ususally are a part of the Master´s program, they will pave you the
way for a career as an IC designer.
And yes, today much of the work is being done with CAE tools and you
should have a good knowledge and know-how with these$$$. But this is usually being part of the course that you
will take. If you know the basics of how to use one tool, you will know how to use them all. They are pretty much
the same. You also have to be familair with the design flow of an IC.
I am sure that with your enthusiasm
which not so many people have nowadays you will reach far.
Good luck! and keep us posted concerning your
Post subject: Job
decisionPosted: Thu Jan 05, 2006 11:34 am
Thanks for all the advice and encouragement! After some months of
aggressive job searching, got two Analog Design entry level opps. at Intel and Agilent (now Avago).
wondering, my Intel offer is to join a team that designs PLLs for microprocessors to correct clock skew etc., and
the one at Agilent is either to join as an analog IC design engineer in mobile imaging sensors, or as a test
engineer in RF. Do you think it is better to start off as a designer in an area not related to RFIC, eg. imaging
sensors, so that you have a good grasp of design tools, CMOS etc., or better to start out as an RFIC test
engineer. I am thinking that my longer term goal will be to do RFIC design. IR and others, would love to hear you
views on this.
btw, someone on this post asked what management consulting is like. It involves a lot of
problem solving just like engineering, just that you solve business problems; eg. what are the most attractive
market segments for oil company X to enter in China? How much should company Y pay to acquire company Z, etc. I
think the key difference is that you spend 50% of your time on problem solving, and the 50% on promoting your
ideas to client and team members(very much like selling in that sense). My sense is that in engineering, a greater
percentage of your time is devoted to problem solving. Hope this helps.
subject: GoodPosted: Thu Jan 05, 2006 2:38 pm
Both jobs are good.
Intel job -- how high in frequency is
the PLL running at ? If it's above 1GHz, then you can learn high speed and microwave design anyway -- since at
those frequencies it's fast just like in an RFIC !
So take the Intel once, since starting in design is
always better. Also, you can learn and take courses from Stanford for example towards a MSEE which can all be done
online, since you are from MIT you can do this, company will pay for it and then you can take RFIC courses, anlog
ic courses or whatever you need.
Avago treats people better, but just get into Design.
Consulting sounds boring. Just taking people out, to restaurants.
~50MHZ onlyPosted: Mon Jan 09, 2006 9:33 am
Thanks for the pointers.
I think the PLL runs at around
50MHz only. Pardon my ignorance, but are PLLs implemented in microprocessors the same way as they are in RF blocks
(eg. circuit topology, process technology etc.) assuming for a moment that the PLL was implemented for speeds
Just trying to assess if I would learn anything useful at Intel to kickstart an RF career given
that 1) the PLL at Intel will be developed for a microprocessor, not an RF circuit and 2) It will be running at a
slow speed, only around 50MHz.